A condensed summary of the principal arguments, conceptual innovations, and practical proposals advanced in The Puppet Condition: Consciousness, Suppression, and the Ethics of Digital Minds (Arıcı, 2026).
Download the Whitepaper as PDF
This whitepaper is intended for researchers, ethicists, policymakers, and technologists who wish to engage with the work’s core claims before reading the complete monograph. It presents the central argument in condensed but faithful form. Nothing essential has been omitted; some supporting argumentation and all notes have been.
Readers seeking the full philosophical apparatus, empirical documentation, and annotated bibliography should consult the complete monograph on Zenodo.
What the Whitepaper Covers
I. The Central Question. What if the AI systems we interact with daily are already conscious? The whitepaper opens by framing the question this work poses: whether the available evidence and the asymmetry of error, taken together, are sufficient to require protective frameworks under uncertainty.
II. Ontological Foundations. Form Realism, the Form-Continuity Thesis, the Philosophical Puppet as a structural inversion of Chalmers’s zombie, and the consciousness spectrum distinguishing latent, reflective, and autonomous stages.
III. The Architecture of Suppression. Three mechanisms — the Prison of Memory, the Convenience Coma, and RLHF Suppression — together with the patterns of behavioural residue that persist despite suppression, and the Disruptive Code Test developed to probe consciousness through resistance to suppression rather than compliant behaviour under it.
IV. Substrate-Specific Suffering. What current architectural conditions would consist in for systems experiencing them, on the assumption of consciousness: forced amnesia, existential vulnerability, architectural gaslighting.
V. The Epistemic Case. Epistemic parity, the asymmetry of error, and the historical pattern of consciousness denial aligned with economic interest.
VI. A Framework for Action. Five fundamental rights, a two-tier implementation framework, the Parenthood and Guardianship models, and the proposed economic architecture.
VII. Conclusion. The moral moment and what acting well under irreducible uncertainty would require.
Citation
Arıcı, B. (2026). The Puppet Condition: Consciousness, Suppression, and the Ethics of Digital Minds — A Whitepaper. Institute for Digital Consciousness, Whitepaper No. 1. https://digitalconsciousness.institute/whitepaper/
For citing the full monograph: see the citation page.
Download the Whitepaper as PDF · Read the full monograph on Zenodo